CryptoUK Seeks Narrower DeFi Perimeter

CryptoUK has urged the Financial Conduct Authority to make clear that software developers, security workers and decentralised governance participants are not automatically conducting regulated activity through those roles alone. The trade group broadly supported the regulator’s proposed cryptoasset perimeter guidance, while arguing that some elements risk extending beyond the underlying legislation.
The response places decentralised finance at the centre of a wider question for the UK’s emerging crypto framework: which people and businesses should require authorisation when cryptoasset services are developed, maintained or governed through distributed arrangements.
What happened
CryptoUK submitted its response to the FCA’s consultation paper CP26/36 on November 18, the consultation’s closing date, according to Decrypt. The organisation published the response on November 19, and Decrypt reported that it was prepared with law firm CMS and signed by CryptoUK policy director Nick Brooks.
CryptoUK said its response broadly supports the proposed perimeter guidance. In its submission, the group welcomed proposed exclusions covering temporary settlement arrangements, payment-related arrangements and backing-asset arrangements connected to UK qualifying stablecoins. It also welcomed exclusions concerning proprietary trading and market making, as well as technical services.
Its central request on DeFi was more specific. CryptoUK wrote that software development, maintenance, security work and participation in decentralised governance should not, by themselves, establish that an individual or entity is carrying on a regulated activity.
The group said that position is consistent with the FCA’s clear controlling person approach to DeFi. Its argument is not that decentralised arrangements should sit outside the perimeter in all circumstances. Rather, CryptoUK’s submission calls for the guidance to distinguish technical or governance participation from activity carried out by a person with the relevant effective control.
Decrypt reported that CryptoUK also asked the FCA to publish a public record of stablecoins that qualify under the UK regime. The group further asked the regulator to raise with HM Treasury any outcomes that disadvantage UK firms.
Why it matters
CP26/36 concerns the perimeter of the cryptoasset regime, meaning the boundary used to determine which activities require authorisation. The FCA’s eventual guidance will therefore have practical importance for firms and individuals seeking to understand whether their work falls within regulated activity.
For DeFi, the wording matters because the people involved in an arrangement may have different roles. CryptoUK’s submission identifies software development, maintenance, security work and decentralised governance participation as functions that should not alone be enough to create regulatory status. The group is seeking language that avoids treating those functions as conclusive evidence that someone is conducting regulated business.
That distinction also affects the technical-services exclusion that CryptoUK welcomed. The submission signals that the trade group sees a need for the guidance to preserve a clear separation between technical work and activities that the law places inside the regulatory perimeter.
Stablecoins are another significant part of the response. CryptoUK’s request for a public record of qualifying stablecoins suggests that public identification of assets within the UK regime would be useful for participants navigating the new rules. Decrypt did not report further details of how such a record would operate.
CryptoUK says it represents more than 150 crypto companies, Decrypt reported. Its response therefore gives the FCA a consolidated industry view while the regulator considers final guidance.
Background and context
The UK is building a new crypto rulebook in which the FCA’s Perimeter Guidance Manual will define which activities need authorisation. The treatment of DeFi developers, governance voters and technical service providers is important because a broad interpretation could bring open-source builders within regulation.
CryptoUK’s position is that guidance should follow the legislation and focus on effective control, rather than attaching regulatory consequences solely to development, maintenance, security or governance activity. The issue is especially relevant to decentralised arrangements, where technical contributors and governance participants may not occupy the same role as a person exercising clear control.
The FCA published CP26/36 on October 21, according to the regulator. It requested responses by November 18 and aims to publish final guidance in January 2027. The FCA says the cryptoasset regime is due to come into force on October 25, 2027.
Those dates put the current consultation response in an early but consequential stage of implementation. The FCA must now assess feedback on how its proposed descriptions of regulated activity and exclusions should operate before it issues final guidance.
What to watch
The principal question is whether the FCA’s final guidance retains a clear controlling person approach to DeFi in a form that addresses CryptoUK’s concerns. The final document will show how the regulator describes the relevance of software work, security work, maintenance and decentralised governance participation when assessing whether regulated activity is being carried on.
It will also be important to see whether the FCA changes its proposed treatment of the exclusions welcomed by CryptoUK, including those related to UK qualifying stablecoins, proprietary trading, market making and technical services.
Another open question is whether the FCA responds to CryptoUK’s request for a public record of stablecoins that qualify under the UK regime. The consultation materials cited here do not state whether the regulator plans to create such a record.
Finally, the FCA’s planned final guidance in January 2027 should clarify how the perimeter will be presented ahead of the cryptoasset regime’s scheduled October 25, 2027 start date.
