Senators Push CFTC on Geoblocks Amid Kalshi, Polymarket Probes

Senate Democrats press CFTC to back off geofencing warning as Kalshi, Polymarket face scrutiny

Nine Democratic U.S. senators are urging the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to withdraw—or at least pause—an agency interpretation that tells regulated prediction-market exchanges to stop restricting access state by state through geofencing or geoblocks.

In a letter led by Sen. Adam Schiff of California, the lawmakers argue the CFTC’s position conflicts with existing court orders that have required certain platforms to stop offering specific contracts in some jurisdictions and to implement geofencing. The senators also asked the agency to preserve records related to the issue dating back to Jan. 1, 2025, and to respond by Nov. 23.

The push comes as Politico reported the CFTC is probing Kalshi, and amid heightened attention on regulated prediction markets such as Kalshi and Polymarket, including questions about how event-contract trading should be supervised.

What the senators are asking for

The letter focuses on a CFTC interpretation dated Nov. 5 that, according to the senators, directs designated contract markets (DCMs) to end geofencing for certain event-contract markets. The lawmakers asked the agency to withdraw the interpretation or freeze it until related litigation is resolved.

At a minimum, they want the CFTC to clarify that geofencing does not violate its rule when the restrictions are:

  • imposed by court order,
  • adopted to comply with federal Indian gaming law or tribal-state compacts, or
  • added voluntarily by an exchange.

The senators wrote that courts have ordered platforms to stop offering certain contracts in Michigan, Nevada, and Washington, as well as on the lands of two California tribes, and that courts have required those platforms to geofence.

The signers included every senator from California, Michigan, Nevada, and Washington—all Democrats—along with Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, the ranking member of the Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC. Other Democrats named in the letter include Richard Blumenthal, Cory Booker, Tim Kaine, Catherine Cortez Masto, and Jacky Rosen.

The CFTC’s position and the state-federal clash

The dispute sits at the center of a broader jurisdictional fight: whether CFTC oversight of DCMs preempts state authorities that seek to restrict or prosecute prediction market offerings under state gambling laws.

CFTC Chairman Mike Selig has argued that DCM regulation under federal law preempts state actions aimed at restricting these products. Earlier this month, the CFTC instructed regulated prediction market exchanges—including Kalshi and Polymarket—that they must operate in all 50 states without restriction, or provide an explanation within 30 days for why they cannot.

Separately, a temporary restraining order in one matter targeted multiple companies, including Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Gemini, and Crypto.com. The CFTC responded by filing a lawsuit to challenge the state’s efforts, and companies including Crypto.com have sought to join the CFTC’s action.

The agency has also sued Arkansas, bringing the number of states it has sued to around a dozen. Arkansas had filed its own case against Kalshi on Nov. 4, accusing the company of operating an illegal gambling business.

Selig has also criticized state-level criminal prosecutions. He pointed to Utah Attorney General Derek Brown’s decision to file 14 criminal charges—13 felonies—against Kalshi co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, alleging the company continued operating in violation of state anti-gambling laws.

Tribal gaming and court rulings

The senators’ letter also highlights the complexity created by tribal gaming law. A court unanimously ruled that Kalshi’s sports-event contracts qualify as unauthorized Class III gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA) when used on tribal lands. The court found that Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch of Me-Wuk Indians were likely to succeed in proving Kalshi and Polymarket operated without a valid gaming compact.

The lawmakers argue the CFTC’s geofencing stance “flies in the face” of court-ordered restrictions, putting exchanges in a position where they may be unable to comply with both judicial rulings and the regulator’s interpretation at the same time.

Kalshi and Polymarket under scrutiny

The letter arrives as Politico reported the CFTC is investigating Kalshi, including whether the company properly notified the agency about dozens of new products. Politico also reported that the CFTC recently warned Kalshi of potential charges that could end in a settlement. A Kalshi spokesperson said the warning “is about a procedural error involving the submission of a handful of contracts, many of which weren’t live.”

The senators also raised broader concerns about event-contract markets, including risks around internal controls and non-public information. The letter cited three Polymarket contracts offered in recent months tied to a NASA spaceship launch, the fate of Venezuela’s authoritarian leader, and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, arguing the episodes underscore the need for safeguards “to prevent insiders from profiting off of non-public information, and direct profiteering off of human suffering.”

The lawmakers also noted that the CFTC “has cleared the way” for Polymarket to reenter the U.S. market after U.S. users were ostensibly blocked from accessing contracts on the company’s offshore exchange.

Why it matters

The outcome of the geofencing dispute could shape how prediction markets operate in the U.S. If the CFTC insists DCMs must offer contracts nationwide without state-by-state blocks, it would reinforce federal primacy over these markets. If courts or Congress push back, platforms could face a more fragmented compliance landscape—especially in states pursuing gambling enforcement and in jurisdictions involving tribal gaming rules.

The CFTC did not immediately respond to a request for comment about the senators’ letter, according to the information provided.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply